We are among those whom we consider most like us for the majority of our
private and social lives. Our family. Our group. Our people, we
consider them to be. We know we belong to, and associate with, bigger
groups of people we may not understand completely. Personally,
culturally or linguistically. We never attempt to speak a foreign
language without understanding what those words mean, the correct
pronunciations and grammar; we learn first. We never attempt to
participate in a culture without understanding the social rules and the
correct way of addressing members of this new cultural society; we learn
first. When first meeting a new associate we do not hop right into
intimate questions regarding their sexual habits; we get to know them
and their boundaries first. So why do we do this with complete
strangers in our own society, our own culture?
It is almost as if we have cannot forget the taunts at school or the
streets where our bullies once believed that in order to be gay, a
person wanted to transition to the other side of the gender binary.
Where we were asked, if we are boys, "Where's your barbie?" or "Where's
your Easy Bake Oven?" Or, if we are girls "Where's your dick? We
fought back because for a moment there we did ask ourselves that
question. Do I unconsciously wish to be the opposite gender because I
am attracted to what the opposite gender is attracted to? We would say,
no.
We fought back by being the best physical example of the gender binary
as we could get. You could look up male or female and find our picture
as the definition. We would beat the crap out of anyone who dared say
we were pretending to be anything we are not. We held onto that like a
shield. To us that is what our sexual orientation meant. It is what
society said sexual orientation meant. We adopted this belief because
it kinda made sense. We are one gender that falls in love with that
same gender. We love everything about that gender. If that gender
"changed" then our sexual orientation "changes" and that is not possible
since we have been fighting against the idea that our sexual
orientation can "change" for years.
Why are we so afraid of embracing the transgender community? Is our
certainty of our personal truth so shaky that the truth of another makes
us question ourselves? Have we really recovered from being bullied
with some false idea that in order to be gay one must want to be the
opposite gender? Before anyone knew we were gay or straight we were
just our name or familial relationship. Our visual gender, and no one
questioned it. We were so and so's son or daughter. The boy or girl
down the street. It is the reason why so many of us question our sexual
orientation. Are we really that insecure? The transgender community
is not "proving them right", they are helping to prove that our
detractors are wrong.
Take the case in Texas where an intersex woman transitioned from the
male body she was assigned and has now married a woman, yet gay marriage
is not legal in Texas. The gay marriage bans are all based on gender.
Only those of opposite GENDER can marry; not sexual orientation. The
law was based on the idea that "legal" gender does not change no matter
what surgical procedures are done to alter the physical body. When,
ironically, it is true gender that does not change, not visual gender.
This is what the opponents of gay marriage believe they have done in
banning gay marriage. Banning the same gender from marrying each other
yet basing the law solely on visual sex/genitalia. Now they are
realising the error with this case.
They based the law on visual gender alone, thinking that is what
governed sexual orientation. Yet, here is a couple that is by all means
gay to societal eyes but the government must allow the marriage because
in the governmental perception of gender, it cannot change therefore
sexual orientation does not. Society says, if you are male and
attracted to men you are gay. If you are male and attracted to females,
you are straight. Born one visual gender; always that gender. The
perception of gender through visual attributes or genitalia.
If the government now tries to change the law to say that gender cannot
be distinguished visually in order to disallow these transgender
couples, on what level can they prove whom is male and whom is female?
We all know the different types of intersex conditions, (http://www.isna.org/faq/what_is_intersex), and many intersex
conditions are not visual. Will everyone have to prove their hormonal,
chromosomal, internal reproductive organ, genital etc. gender in order
to marry? Or will the government simply do what is right and not
interfere as long as it is two consenting adults? Hetero-sexism and
homophobia, internal and external, is based on perception of gender.
The perception of a gender binary in particular. If those who made
these arguments against gay rights finally realise that no one can
determine gender except the individual, their arguments are baseless.
We are afraid of the transgender community because we see gender as the
reason behind our sexual orientation. We believe that men are men and
women are women and never the two should be "changed" or "altered". We
are gay, or straight, and we believe it is those visual attributes of
gender that drives our orientation. If we loved someone who we then
came to believe "altered" or "changed" from that physical representation
of gender we begin to question our sexual orientation. We start
doubting our sexual orientation because we base it on love of visual
gender than person.
We distrust those who are bi-sexual since, from society's perspective,
their sexual orientation changes. When they are with the same visual
gender they are gay yet when they are with the opposite visual gender
they are straight. We do not trust our relationships with our bi-sexual
partners because in the back of our mind we are saying "How do we know
they will STAY straight or gay?" Refusing to acknowledge that they are
not fixated on visual gender but us. We refuse to see that they love
us, the person, the one who listens, who likes whatever genre of music
we love, who's always there for support; us.
We believe that is not possible because to us visual gender is the focus
of sexual orientation. We simply cannot let go of our grip on visual
gender. One or the other. It is the reason for bi and trans-phobia.
The trans-panic defense can also be tied to the gay community not just
the straight. Trans-panic means "I'm not straight!" as much as it means
"I'm not gay!" and "I'm not Bi!"
I'll go as far as to say this. If an effeminate gay man stood still and
did not talk the gay men who say they do not like effeminate men would
want to date him. It's not the physical man they are not attracted to,
it is the "feminine" personality. The blurring of that gender
perception line. The perception that a breathy tone, self-conscious
giggles, emotional displays and a sensual walk is inherent to the
visually feminine gender only. It makes them question "Am I really gay
if I like this guy?" To many, that "feminine" personality should not
exist in a "masculine" body. When will they realise it is the person
they are attracted to? We can lust after a body all we want but we know
that no matter how hot the body if the personality, the person, isn't
what we are looking for the body loses it's attraction.
Visual gender and sexual orientation are simply societal perceptions of
human relationships. We are always the gender society sees unless we
tell society who we truly are. Our sexual orientation is always what
society sees, by way of our perceived relationships, unless we tell
society who we truly are. Only we know who we are, who we are attracted
to, and whom we love. Only we can define our relationships.
That is why we have such a hard time understanding the transgender
community since we base everything on our perceptions instead of letting
people introduce themselves. If the couple that is involved in the
ongoing legal determination of marriage in Texas were still visually man
and woman, we would say they were heterosexual, now that they are
trans-woman and woman we perceive them to be lesbian. I'm sure they
only see themselves as partners and lovers. The rest can go hang.
Recent Comments